Skip to content

Semiconductor switches and their losses

  • Model a MOSFET that is on as a resistance, and a conducting diode as a forward voltage plus a small resistance.
  • Estimate the capacitive turn-on loss and the gate-drive power, and see how both scale with the switching frequency.
  • Tell the losses that grow with the switching frequency from those that grow with the load.

An ideal switch has no voltage across it when on and no current through it when off. A converter realizes its switches with transistors, such as MOSFETs, and diodes [Erickson & Maksimović 2020, Ch. 4]. A transistor is turned on and off by its gate; a diode switches by itself, conducting when it is forward-biased and blocking when it is reverse-biased [Erickson & Maksimović 2020, Ch. 4].

A MOSFET that is fully on behaves as a resistance, its on-resistance, so its conduction loss follows from its rms current (conduction loss). A conducting diode is modelled by a constant forward voltage in series with a small resistance [Erickson & Maksimović 2020, Ch. 3]:

P=VFIavg+rdIrms2P = V_F I_\mathrm{avg} + r_d I_\mathrm{rms}^{2}
PP
power
IavgI_\mathrm{avg}
average current
IrmsI_\mathrm{rms}
rms current
VFV_F
diode forward voltage
rdr_d
diode dynamic resistance
Diode conduction loss✓ verified by 7 tests
Assumptions, convention and source
Assumptions
  • periodic steady state
Source
Erickson & Maksimović 2020, Ch. 3 (Steady-State Equivalent Circuit Modeling, Losses, and Efficiency)
Derivation
step-by-step sympy derivation
Equation id
loss.diode · equations.yaml entry

The forward voltage takes a fixed voltage from the circuit whatever the current, so it costs the most efficiency when the output voltage is low [Erickson & Maksimović 2020, Ch. 4].

When the transistor turns on, it discharges the capacitance at the switch node, which includes its own output capacitance. The energy stored in that capacitance is lost in every period [Erickson & Maksimović 2020, Ch. 4]:

P=CnodeVsw2fs2P = \frac{C_\mathrm{node} V_\mathrm{sw}^{2} f_s}{2}
PP
power
CnodeC_\mathrm{node}
switch-node capacitance
VswV_\mathrm{sw}
switch-node voltage at turn-on
fsf_s
switching frequency
Capacitive turn-on loss✓ verified by 7 tests
Assumptions, convention and source
Assumptions
  • periodic steady state
  • the capacitance is fully discharged at every turn-on
  • all of the stored energy is dissipated every cycle
Source
Erickson & Maksimović 2020, Ch. 4 (Switch Realization)
Derivation
step-by-step sympy derivation
Equation id
loss.sw.cap · equations.yaml entry

In addition, the current and the voltage overlap for a short time during each transition, and the diode’s stored charge must be removed when it turns off; both add loss at every switching event [Erickson & Maksimović 2020, Ch. 4].

To switch a MOSFET, the driver moves the gate charge from its supply into the gate and then back to ground, once per period. The power this takes is dissipated in the driver and the gate resistances, not in the MOSFET’s channel [Balogh 2018]:

P=QgVGSfsP = Q_g V_\mathrm{GS} f_s
PP
power
QgQ_g
total gate charge
VGSV_\mathrm{GS}
gate-drive voltage
fsf_s
switching frequency
Gate-drive power✓ verified by 7 tests
Assumptions, convention and source
Assumptions
  • periodic steady state
Notes
dissipated in the driver and gate resistances, not in the power switch channel
Source
Balogh 2018
Derivation
step-by-step sympy derivation
Equation id
loss.gate · equations.yaml entry

An example switch node, gate drive and diode:

Switch and diode loss example
SymbolValueHow it is obtained
CnodeC_\mathrm{node} switch-node capacitance100 pFgiven
VswV_\mathrm{sw} switch-node voltage at turn-on48 Vgiven
fsf_s switching frequency100 kHzgiven
QgQ_g total gate charge20 nCgiven
VGSV_\mathrm{GS} gate-drive voltage10 Vgiven
VFV_F diode forward voltage500 mVgiven
IavgI_\mathrm{avg} average current1 Agiven
rdr_d diode dynamic resistance50 mΩgiven
IrmsI_\mathrm{rms} rms current1.2 Agiven
Psw{P}_{\mathrm{sw}} power11.5 mWCapacitive turn-on loss
Pgate{P}_{\mathrm{gate}} power20 mWGate-drive power
Pdiode{P}_{\mathrm{diode}} power572 mWDiode conduction loss

At this switching frequency the capacitive turn-on loss is 11.5 mW and the gate-drive power 20 mW; both double if the switching frequency doubles. The diode’s conduction loss, 572 mW, depends on the load current instead.

▶ Open in the equation explorer: Capacitive turn-on loss
Preset from the example switch-losses

Sweep the switched voltage on its logarithmic axis: the capacitive loss grows with its square, which is why this loss matters most in converters that switch high voltages. Then open the gate-drive equation and sweep the switching frequency.

On a buck evaluation board whose switching frequency can be set, measure the input and output power at a fixed load with a power analyzer or with a multimeter pair on each side, at two switching frequencies. The increase in loss divided by the increase in frequency estimates the energy lost per switching period; compare it with the capacitive-loss and gate-drive equations, using the capacitance and gate charge from the data sheets.

  • Losses that happen once per period scale with frequency. A higher switching frequency shrinks the inductor needed for a given ripple, but the capacitive, transition and gate-drive losses rise in proportion [Erickson & Maksimović 2020, Ch. 4].
  • Gate power heats the driver, not the MOSFET. Budget it in the driver’s dissipation [Balogh 2018].
  • A diode drop is costly at low output voltage. The same forward voltage is a larger fraction of a low output voltage, which is why low-voltage converters often replace the diode by a transistor, a synchronous rectifier [Erickson & Maksimović 2020, Ch. 4].
  1. At every turn-on, a transistor discharges 100 pF100\,\mathrm{pF} at the switch node from 48 V48\,\mathrm{V}, at 200 kHz200\,\mathrm{kHz}. What is the capacitive turn-on loss?

    1. 11.5 mW11.5\,\mathrm{mW}
    2. 23 mW23\,\mathrm{mW}
    3. 46 mW46\,\mathrm{mW}
    4. 2.3 mW2.3\,\mathrm{mW}
    Answer and explanation

    Correct answer: B The stored energy is half the capacitance times the square of the voltage, about 115 nJ115\,\mathrm{nJ}, lost 2×1052 \times 10^5 times per second.

  2. A MOSFET with a total gate charge of 30 nC30\,\mathrm{nC} is driven with 12 V12\,\mathrm{V} at 100 kHz100\,\mathrm{kHz}. What is the gate-drive power?

    1. 3.6 mW3.6\,\mathrm{mW}
    2. 18 mW18\,\mathrm{mW}
    3. 36 mW36\,\mathrm{mW}
    4. 360 mW360\,\mathrm{mW}
    Answer and explanation

    Correct answer: C The gate charge times the drive voltage is the energy per period, 360 nJ360\,\mathrm{nJ}, taken 10510^5 times per second.

  3. The switching frequency is doubled. What happens to the capacitive turn-on loss and to the gate-drive power?

    1. Both double
    2. Both are unchanged
    3. The first doubles, the second is unchanged
    4. Both quadruple
    Answer and explanation

    Correct answer: A Each is a fixed energy lost once per period, so both are proportional to the switching frequency.

  4. Where is the gate-drive power dissipated?

    1. In the MOSFET's channel
    2. In the driver and the gate resistances
    3. In the load
    4. Nowhere: the gate charge is recovered
    Answer and explanation

    Correct answer: B The gate charge flows through the driver and the gate resistances on its way in and out, and they turn its energy into heat.

  5. A diode with a 0.5 V0.5\,\mathrm{V} forward voltage and 20 mΩ20\,\mathrm{m}\Omega of slope resistance carries 2 A2\,\mathrm{A} on average and 2.5 A2.5\,\mathrm{A} rms. What is its conduction loss?

    1. 1 W1\,\mathrm{W}
    2. 1.125 W1.125\,\mathrm{W}
    3. 1.25 W1.25\,\mathrm{W}
    4. 0.125 W0.125\,\mathrm{W}
    Answer and explanation

    Correct answer: B The forward voltage times the average current gives 1 W1\,\mathrm{W}, and the slope resistance times the square of the rms current adds 0.125 W0.125\,\mathrm{W}.

  6. Why do low-voltage converters often replace the output diode by a synchronous rectifier?

    1. Diodes cannot block low voltages
    2. The diode's fixed forward voltage is a large fraction of a low output voltage, so it costs much of the efficiency
    3. A synchronous rectifier needs no gate drive
    4. Diodes switch too slowly at any voltage
    Answer and explanation

    Correct answer: B The forward voltage takes a fixed voltage from the output path whatever the load; a transistor that is on drops only its on-resistance times the current.

The numbers in the examples, presets and exercises on this site are synthetic: round teaching values, not data from any real design.